Thursday, August 11, 2022

Chapter 11 Trustee Recovers Enhanced Lodestar for Superior Result

 Bankruptcy trustees often perform a thankless job, scrubbing through thousands of no-asset files looking for that one case that will earn them a sizeable commission. While Chapter 7 trustees are paid a commission on funds distributed to creditors, compensation for Chapter 11 trustees more closely resembles an hourly fee engagement. A recent case from Judge Tony Davis of the Western District of Texas illustrates how the two forms of compensation may dramatically differ. In re WC Met Center, LLC, Case No. 21-10698 (Bankr. W.D. Tex. 7/15/22). The opinion can be found here. 

Sunday, July 31, 2022

Another Alex Jones Entity Seeks Bankruptcy Protection

 Faced with pending trials to establish liability for defamation, another Alex Jones entity has decided to test the waters of bankruptcy. On Friday July 29, 2022, Free Speech Systems, LLC, the company which actually produces the Alex Jones Show and his other programming, filed a petition under Subchapter V of Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas, Victoria Division. Case No. 22-60043.  In April, three minor entities within the Jones organization filed bankruptcy in an attempt to channel liability away from Jones and Free Speech Solutions. Those cases met substantial resistance and were voluntarily dismissed. 

Friday, July 22, 2022

Nevertheless, FERC Persisted

When U.S. Sen Elizabeth Warren continued to speak at the confirmation hearing for AG Jeff Sessions after being cautioned by Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, it gave rise to the feminist slogan, "Nevertheless, she persisted." A new opinion from the Fifth Circuit adapts that slogan to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's attempts to prevent debtors from rejecting regulatory energy contracts. Judge Jerry Smith's opinion in Case No. 21-60017, Gulfport Energy Corporation v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (5th Cir. 7/19/22) points out that the Fifth Circuit and others have held that debtors "may 'reject' regulated energy contracts even if (FERC) would not like them to." Noting that FERC continued to press the issue, Judge Smith noted that "Nevertheless, FERC persisted." While many believe that Sen. Warren got the better of Majority Leader McConnell in their exchange, the Bankruptcy Code came out on top in the Fifth Circuit's new decision.

Wednesday, June 08, 2022

What Is the Difference Between Clerical and Compensable?

 A short order crossed my desk the other day in In re Preferred Ready-Mix, Case No. 21-33369 (Bankr. S.D. Tex. 6/6/22), Dkt. #207. A creditor filed an application for administrative expense. No one objected. However, the Court reduced the fees requested by $73.50 to reflect time spent electronically filing documents. While this little case involves much smaller dollars than the Supreme Court opinion in Siegel v. Fitzgerald, No. 21-411 (U.S. 6/6/22), which came out the same day, it will affect many more cases.

A Little Background

When it comes to professional compensation, there are three types of services. First, there are professional services, which require the skill and knowledge of an attorney and, are compensable at rates which can exceed over $1,000 per hour in some cases. Then there are para-professional tasks, where are those which require skill and knowledge, but do not require a licensed attorney and are compensated at lower rates. Finally, there are clerical tasks, which do not require specialized knowledge and are not compensable because they are deemed to be part of a firm's overhead. 

What Judge Norman Ruled

In his Judge Norman stated:

The Court notes that no objection to the application has been filed. However, the Court has an independent duty to review fee applications, notwithstanding the absence of objections by the United States Trustee, creditors, or any other interested party. The Supreme Court has held that the lodestar method of fee calculation is the method by which federal courts should determine reasonable attorney fees under federal statutes which provide for such fees. The lodestar is computed by multiplying the number of hours reasonably expended by the prevailing hourly rate in the community for similar work. The first step in the lodestar method is to evaluate the time entries submitted by the Applicant and determine which are allowable. This step involves considering whether the services which the Applicant billed were reasonable or necessary. The services performed must be legal in nature, rather than clerical. This application contains instances of the applicant’s billing for work which is routinely performed by secretaries and should not be billed to the client. Case law suggests that “ministerial tasks” (typing, file organization, document preparation, searching or filing documents on PACER, etc.) performed by a professional or paraprofessional should not be allowed as a separate charge because it is part of the office overhead, which should already be built into the counsel’s hourly rate. This Court considers ECF filing to be clerical work, and therefore, should not be allowed as a separate charge. The instant fee application contains several instances where counsel billed for filing ECF documents. Therefore, those entries containing secretarial tasks will be struck.

What are Clerical Tasks?

 According to Judge Norman, filing documents on ECF is a  secretarial task. This suggests that filing documents on CM/ECF is a routine task to be performed by a low level employee and certainly does not require the assistance of an attorney. When electronic filing first came out, there was a debate over whether it would ever be permissible for an attorney to give his staff access to his e-filing credentials. The logic was that the orders adopting e-filing expressly provided that inputting an attorneys' login and password constituted his signature upon the document. Since an attorney could not ethically allow his secretary to sign his name to a pleading, it was reasoned that an attorney could not authorize his secretary to file a pleading or motion on his behalf. However, when the courts began offering e-filing courses aimed at attorney staff, it was at least an implicit acknowledgement that the courts did not treat the use of e-filing credentials as being the same as a signature.

The consensus is now that e-filing in bankruptcy by attorney staff is ethical, but is it clerical? Judge Norman gave several examples of other tasks that are considered clerical:  typing, file organization, document preparation and searching or filing documents on PACER. As someone who supervises clerical staff, I would add making copies, mailing documents and putting documents in the file to the list. 

What distinguishes this list from compensable para-professional tasks? I think it is a matter of training and skill. While it does require training and skill to type a document in Microsoft Word or to print out postage on stamps.com, the skill required is not inherently legal. In other words, these are skills that anyone working in an office would be expected to know or learn. On the other hand, para-professionals may charge for tasks that require skills and knowledge unique to the legal field, and in particular, those unique to bankruptcy.

I would argue that e-filing documents requires sufficient skill and knowledge that a para-professional may charge for those services. In order to file a document electronically, a user must be able to know how the e-filing menu interacts with the local rules of the particular court. An example involving two first-day pleadings may help. In an operating chapter 11 case, it is common to file a motion for use of cash collateral and a motion to pay employee wages as first day motions. In the Southern District of Texas, any pleading requiring expedited consideration must be labelled as an emergency motion, be filed using the emergency motion event code and must contain special language as part of the negative notice. In the Western District of Texas, there is a specific event code for motions for use of cash collateral but not for motions to pay employee wages. Motions to pay employee wages must be uploaded as a generic document. In the Southern District proposed orders are attached to the associated motion but are not uploaded. In the Western District of Texas, proposed orders are both attached to the pleading and are uploaded. These are not distinctions that a mere secretary, someone who could just as easily work in a law office or a dentist's office, would know.  

This was brought home to me when I filed a Chapter 11 case in the Southern District this week. I used to have a legal assistant who was skilled in e-filing. However, my current assistant has not received this training yet. As a result, I had to do the e-filing myself. Because I have not filed many Chapter 11 cases in the Southern District (yet), it took me some time to figure out how to formulate the pleadings and how to e-file them. It took me an hour to upload the case and three first day motions (one of which was rejected). For me, this was a throw-back to the days when only attorneys were allowed to e-file. (Since my case was in Judge Norman's court, I billed the time but no-charged it). 

Judge Jernigan Debuts Her Second Novel

Judge Stacey C.G. Jernigan is best known for the writing she publishes from her office at 1100 Commerce Street. I was able to locate 270 of her opinions on LEXIS. Some of my favorites are In re Tinsley, 2010 Bankr. LEXIS 4156 (Bankr. N.D. Tex. 20100 about a cowboy trying to keep the ranch he inherited from his father and In re Pearson, 2020 Bankr. LEXIS 972 (Bankr. N.D. Tex. 2020) in which Judge Jernigan cited an article that I wrote. Lee v. Weatherford (In re Weatherford), 2022 Bankr. LEXIS 144 (Bankr. N.D. Tex. 2020) is an opinion about whether a debt arising from a bar brawl was nondischargeable and is just the type of case a Texas judge might encounter.  However, Judge Jernigan is also a novelist. This summer I have enjoyed reading He Watches All My Paths (2019) and Hedging Death (2022).

Sunday, June 05, 2022

Fiffth Circuit Restricts Rooker-Feldman Doctrine Allowing Race to the Courthouse

The Fifth Circuit has issued a new decision restricting application of the Rooker-Feldman doctrine and repudiating a prior precedent.  Miller v. Dunn, Case No. 20-11054 (5th Cir. 6/2/22), which can be found here. Under the new rule, which brings the Fifth Circuit in line with other courts, Rooker-Feldman does not apply to a state court decision which is the subject of a pending appeal.

Rooker-Feldman is one of several doctrines which enforces comity between state and federal courts. The Rooker-Feldman doctrine, which is based on Rooker v. Fidelity Trust Co., 263 U.S. 413 (1923), and District of Columbia Court of Appeals v. Feldman, 460 U.S. 462 (1983) means that a federal court may not review and reverse a determination of a state court. Rooker-Feldman applies to "cases brought by state-court losers complaining of injuries caused by state-court judgments rendered before the district court proceedings commenced and inviting district court review and rejection of those judgments." Exxon Mobil Corp. v. Saudi Basic Indus. Corp., 544 U.S. 280, 284 (2005).

Thursday, June 02, 2022

Judge Michael Parker Addresses the Dead Debtor Problem

 While it is not pleasant to contemplate, sometimes a debtor passes away before his case is completed. This raises the question of whether the case can go to completion and how to complete the financial management class. Judge Michael Parker addressed this issue in one of his first published opinions as a judge. (This is actually his third opinion, but the first one that I had the time to write about).  In re Ibarra, Case No. 19-52413 (Bankr. W.D. Tex. 6/1/2022), which can be found here.

What Happened

The Debtor filed Chapter 13 and confirmed a plan in 2019. The Debtor passed away on October 9, 2021 prior to completing payments under the Plan and before completing a personal financial management course. The debtor's probate estate representative and daughter made the remaining payments under the plan and moved for an order waiving the debtor's obligation to complete a financial management course. As the Judge succinctly stated, "Death prevents the Debtor from completing a financial management course." Opinion, p. 1.

Thursday, May 26, 2022

Debtor's Attorney Commended in Case Denying Objection to Discharge

 No attorney wants to see his name mentioned prominently in an opinion. However, if it has to happen, it's better if its something like this:  "Chance McGhee is an experienced and competent attorney that has practiced consumer bankruptcy law for many years." Adv. No. 21-5036; Wilson v. Silva (In re Silva) (Bankr. W.D. Tex. 5/19/2022).  The opinion can be found here. As the opinion lays out, Mr. McGhee demonstrated how an experienced and competent attorney should handle a potentially difficult case.

Saturday, April 23, 2022

Alex Jones: The Bankruptcy Prequel

 While Alex Jones has created a lot of controversy through his decision to play three of his entities into voluntary bankruptcy, this was not his first brush with bankruptcy. In 2020, his ex-wife, Kelly R. Jones, initiated an involuntary bankruptcy petition against him. In re Jones, Case No. 20-10118 (Bankr. W. D. Texas). Ms. Jones filed the petition pro se, meaning that she did not have a lawyer. The case was dismissed after the bankruptcy court determined that Ms. Jones was not an unsecured creditor. Only unsecured creditors are entitled to bring involuntary bankruptcy petitions. The Bankruptcy Court determined that Ms. Jones's claim of $786,861 was secured by property worth at least $1,250,000. (Dkt. #92). Although Mr. Jones could have sought to recover his legal fees incurred in defending against the petition, he did not.

Thursday, April 21, 2022

Next Phase of Alex Jones Bankruptcy Gambit Unfolds

When Alex Jones filed bankruptcy for three of his entities holding intellectual property and contract rights, it wasn't immediately clear how these filings would help him resolve his larger legal problems. Now it has unfolded that Mr. Jones is using the bankruptcy filings as a vehicle for removing state court actions against him to federal court.  On April 18, 2022, attorneys for the Debtors removed eight state court lawsuits to U.S. Bankruptcy Court: five in Texas and three in Connecticut. 

Tuesday, April 19, 2022

The Alex Jones Bankruptcy Gambit

 In a widely misunderstood move, Alex Jones and his legal team have put three of his entities that own intellectual property assets into SubChapter V of Chapter 11. The move, if successful, will protect the domain name, infowars.com, and will delay entry of judgments against Jones personally. The move involves apparent forum shopping and clever use of SubChapter V. The cases are jointly administered under Case. No. 22-60020 in the Southern District of Texas, Victoria Division.

Monday, March 21, 2022

Southern District of Texas Conducts Spring Cleaning of Noticing

Every day bankruptcy clerks sent out millions of required notifications to creditors and parties in interest. Creditors can bypass the paper notification by designating an email address for service pursuant to Fed.R.Bankr.P. 9036. Now the Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas is seeking to compel high volume creditors to sign up for electronic noticing.  On March 17, 2022, Judge Marvin Isgur instituted 328 orders requiring creditors to appear for a status conference through counsel to explain why they have not signed up for electronic noticing. 

Monday, March 14, 2022

Fifth Circuit Opinion Illustrates Risks of Class Proofs of Claim

A new opinion from the Fifth Circuit highlights the perils of class proofs of claim, something I recently wrote about here. In West Wilmington Oilfield Claimants v. Nabors Corporate Services, Inc. (Matter of CJ Holding Company), Case No. 21-20394 (5th Cir. 3/10/22), the Fifth Circuit upheld a bankruptcy court decision which denied creditors covered by a putative class claim permission to file late claims. The opinion can be found here.

What Happened

In 2015, two former employees of an oilfield services company filed a class action in California state court. C & J Well Services, the defendant, removed the case to federal court. The defendant sought to enforce a company-wide arbitration agreement and class action waiver. The district court denied the motion. C & J appealed the case to the Ninth Circuit.

In July 2016, while the appeal was pending, C & J and several of its affiliates filed bankruptcy in the Southern District of Texas. The Court entered an order setting a bar date and the deadline was advertised in national publications as well as by notice sent to creditors. The putative class representatives filed a proof of claim on behalf of the class for over $14 million. Twenty-seven individual claimants filed their own proofs of claim. A plan was confirmed which denied and expunged all claims filed after the bar date.

The Debtor also entered into a settlement agreement with Nabors Corporate Services to indemnify it for any allowed claims and authorized Nabors to object to any claims subject to the indemnity agreement. Nabors was an affiliate of a company which had merged into the Debtor which had employed the persons bringing the employment claims.

In February 2017, the bankruptcy court issued an order allowing the parties to the Ninth Circuit appeal to prosecute the appeal. In February 2018, the Ninth Circuit reversed the District Court and held that the arbitration and class waiver provisions were enforceable. Ninety-six claimants filed individual arbitration proceedings. However, only twenty-seven of these had filed individual proofs of claim.

In October 2018, Nabors filed an omnibus objection to the various employment proofs of claim. The Bankruptcy Court ruled that the two class representatives and the twenty-seven additional creditors who had filed individual proofs of claim could proceed with the arbitrations but that the remainder could not rely on the class proof of claim.

The Bankruptcy Court advised the claimants who had not filed claims that they could request leave to file late claims. The non-filing claimants did not file their motion for late-filed claims until August 2019, nearly two years after the bar date. After a hearing the Bankruptcy Court denied the motion. The claimants appealed to the District Court which reversed. Nabors then appealed to the Fifth Circuit. 
 
The Court's Ruling

The Fifth Circuit ruled that the Bankruptcy Court was correct in denying leave to file a late claim. How a tardily filed claim treated depends on the chapter. In Chapter 7, a late-filed claim is allowed but is subordinated to all timely-filed claims. 11 U.S.C. Sec. 726(a)(3). There is no provision for late-filed claims in Chapter 13, except that a debtor or trust may file a claim for a creditor within thirty days from the original bar date. In Chapter 11, a claim may be filed after the bar date if the late filing was the result of "excusable neglect." The Supreme Court has established a four-part test for excusable neglect: (1) “the danger of prejudice to the debtor,” (2) “the length of the delay and its potential impact on judicial proceedings,” (3) “the reason for the delay, including whether it was within the reasonable control of the movant,” and (4) “whether the movant acted in good faith.” Opinion, p. 8. 

The Fifth Circuit concluded that the risk of prejudice to the debtor weighed in favor of the claimants because the claims were known to the debtor and because Nabors had agreed to indemnify the debtor. 
 
However, the length of delay was another story. The creditors waited two years and nine months after the bar date had passed and one year and seven months after the Ninth Circuit held that the class action was not a viable remedy.  Adding 67 more arbitrations would add anywhere from two to three months to years to the process. 
 
Next the court found that the claimants had failed to reasonably explain the cause for the delay.  Excusable neglect "is the failure to timely perform a duty due to circumstances that were beyond the reasonable control of the person whose duty it was to perform." The Court found that most of the reasons proffered for the late filings were within the reasonable control of the creditors. 
 
Finally, the Court ruled against the claimants on the good faith prong. 
The Debtors argue that the Claimants’ and their counsel’s failure to act diligently throughout the bankruptcy proceeding was so severe that it undermines their argument that they acted in good faith. We agree. To be sure, we have not held authoritatively that lack of diligence constitutes bad faith per se. Nor do we do so now. But other courts have held, in persuasive fashion, that lack of diligence can at least cast doubt on a claim of good faith.
Opinion, p. 19. Thus, the Fifth Circuit agreed with the Bankruptcy Court with regard to three out of four factors. The Court noted that the standard of review was deferential to the Bankruptcy Court and thus reinstated its ruling denying leave to amend. 

Why It's Significant

This case illustrates the danger in filing a class proof of claim. In evaluating good faith, the Court stated:
Granted, the majority of circuits that have addressed the issue permit class proofs of claim. (citation omitted). However, this court has not spoken definitively on the issue. Yet, since 2016, the Claimants have ostensibly proceeded under the assumption that a class proof of claim would ultimately be available to them. Such is not settled law in this Circuit, and the Claimants’ reliance on unsettled law casts serious doubt on their claim of good faith.
Second, even if the Claimants had moved the bankruptcy court to apply Rule 23 to their purported class proof of claim, they had a second hurdle to overcome. Namely, the bankruptcy court would still have had to certify the class proof of claim. Only once the bankruptcy court determines, in its discretion, that Rule 23 applies does it then evaluate whether the proposed class meets Rule 23’s requirements.
Opinion, pp. 20-21. There are many things that can go wrong when individual creditors rely on a putative class rep to file a class claim. First, the jurisdiction might conclude that there is no authority for class claims. The class rep might fail to seek class certification in the bankruptcy court. If class certification is sought and denied, it would likely be after the bar date. 

One question that is left unanswered by the opinion is the specific notice that the individual claimants received. Notice is essential to due process. It is the debtor's burden to provide that notice. Given that twenty-nine claimants knew to file claims, there is an inference that notice was good. 
 
So what should the putative class reps have done? First, they should have moved for class certification immediately in the Bankruptcy Court. As I have discussed elsewhere, Fed.R.Bankr.P. 7023 allows class actions in bankruptcy. However, there is no specific rule authorizing class proofs of claim. Thus, a class claim must be treated as a class action within the bankruptcy. Second, the putative class reps should have moved to extend the bar date for claimants within the class prior to expiration of the bar date. It is much easier to extend the bar date before it has expired than it is to get permission for a late-filed claim. Finally, this case illustrates why creditors should engage knowledgeable bankruptcy counsel before dealing with these difficult issues. 






Thursday, March 10, 2022

Trustee Who Sought Turnover of Contract Receivable Bound by Arbitration Clause

A trustee who sought "turnover" of amounts owed under a construction contract had an arbitration clause in that contract enforced against him. The Bankruptcy Court found that the bankruptcy exception to enforcement of an arbitration clause was narrow and did not apply to a construction dispute. Satija v.  Kella (In re Davila General Contractors, LLC), Adv. No. 21-1047 (Bankr. W.D. Tex. 3/9/22). The order can be found on CM/ECF at Docket #23.

Tuesday, March 08, 2022

Fifth Circuit Upholds Injunctive Relief Against Single-Member Limited Liability Company

 One of the benefits of holding property or doing business through a limited liability company is that "entry of a charging order is the exclusive remedy by which a judgment creditor of a member or of any other owner of a membership interest may satisfy a judgment out of the judgment debtor's membership interest." Tex.Bus.Org. Code Sec. 101.112(d). But just how exclusive is that right? A recent Fifth Circuit opinion holds that a court may impose additional conditions on a judgment debtor's LLC in the name of carrying out the court's orders.  Thomas v. Hughes, Case No. 20-50827 (5th Cir. 3/3/22), a copy of which can be found here.

Friday, March 04, 2022

A Look at the Jurisprudence of Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson (Bankruptcy and Otherwise)

Supreme Court nominee Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson has played a variety of roles in her legal career. She has been a public defender, an attorney in private practice, a member of the U.S. Sentencing Commission, a U.S. District Judge and a Court of Appeals Judge. Unfortunately, these jobs have given her scant exposure to bankruptcy law. I will explore all three of her bankruptcy related opinions (out of a total of about 600) as well as a handful of her other jurisprudence.

Tuesday, February 22, 2022

Class Proofs of Claim Create Procedural Minefield

Bankruptcy has been likened to a class action. In a typical class action, a class representative files suit against a defendant seeking relief on behalf of a class of plaintiff. If class certification is not granted, the suit continues as a conventional suit. In bankruptcy, a debtor files for relief against his or her creditors. However, as shown by Fed.R.Bankr.P. 7023, it is possible to have a traditional class action within the collective proceeding of a bankruptcy. Sometimes this is done through the vehicle of filing a class proof of claim. However, unless an actual class of claims is certified, a "class" proof of claim is just a regular proof of claim. 

Friday, February 11, 2022

Fifth Circuit Opinion Upholds Limits on Actions Between Non-Debtors

 In a case involving multiple parties and proceedings, the Fifth Circuit has affirmed lower court rulings which prohibited one non-debtor from suing a second non-debtor and awarded sanctions against a party that told a state court to disregard the Bankruptcy Court's orders. In the Matter of PFO Global, Incorporated, Case No. 20-10885 (5th Cir. 2/9/22), which can be found here. While the result may sound extreme, it appears to be an unintended consequence of an agreed order entered years earlier.

Wednesday, February 02, 2022

District Court Finds Plan Provision So Broad It Exceeded Jurisdiction

While bankruptcy subject matter jurisdiction is broad, sometimes an order can just go too far as shown by the recent opinion from the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia in Patterson v. Mahway Bergen  Retail Group, Inc., 2022 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 7431 (E.D. Va. 2022).

The Three Types of Jurisdiction

Bankruptcy practitioners can usually recite the three types of bankruptcy jurisdiction in their sleep: arising in, arising under and related to. Of these, related to is the broadest. In the Fifth Circuit, related to jurisdiction is present if the matter being addressed could have a conceivable effect on the debtor or the bankruptcy estate. Thus, if the debtor owned a store at the bottom of a hill and a property owner had allowed a boulder at the top of the hill to work precariously loose, an adversary proceeding to force the other property owner to secure the boulder would have a conceivable effect on the bankruptcy estate and related to jurisdiction would be present. Why is this? If the boulder rolled down the hill, it could smash the debtor's store. On a more mundane note, there is related to jurisdiction to collect accounts receivable owed to the debtor because collecting money would make it easier to reorganize.

In the past, there were many arguments about whether bankruptcy courts had jurisdiction to grant third-party releases. The Supreme Court put this controversy to rest in United Student Aid Funds v. Espinosa, 559 U.S. 260 (2010). In that case, the Supreme Court drew a distinction between having statutory authority to take an action and having jurisdiction to do so. The Bankruptcy Code does not allow a court to grant a hardship discharge on a student loan without filing an adversary proceeding. However, there is clearly jurisdiction to do so because granting the discharge would have a conceivable effect on the debtor. What this means is that if a plan contains a provision which should not be approved, the parties have to challenge it directly as opposed to coming back years later and saying that there was no jurisdiction to approve the provision.

Friday, January 21, 2022

Defaulting Auction Bidder Finds Evidentiary Mess

A new opinion from the Fifth Circuit shows multiple mishaps in connection with a bankruptcy-related auction. However, its most important holding has to do with authenticating evidence. The bottom line is that a trial court decision limiting a defaulting bidder's damages based on a webpage found on the Wayback Machine was reversed. Weinhoffer v. Davie Shoring, Inc., Case No. 20-30568 (5th Cir. 1/20/22).  You can find the opinion here.